Cayuga Lake Fishing: Depth, Species & Tips

Cayuga Lake is a lake in New York, USA, covering roughly 42,907 acres. Depth: about 436 ft max depth. Water clarity: Stained (~2.6 m Secchi).

Cayuga Lake at a glance

Fish species in Cayuga Lake

Also present: Round Goby, White Sucker, Freshwater Drum, Pumpkinseed, Alewife, Chain Pickerel, Creek Chub, Riffle Daces, Siamese Fighting Fish, Central Stoneroller, Mottled Sculpin, European Carp, Spotfin Shiner.

Species are those recorded within 14 km of the lake in iNaturalist and GBIF records — not an official lake survey. Confirm locally.

Regulations change every year — always confirm the current official rules before you fish.

🏅 Record fish from Cayuga Lake

Official records caught in this lake, from state and provincial record lists
New York state record

Largemouth Bass

12 lb 6 oz25 in
James Britenbaugh · Jul 11, 2024

Caught on a Senko.

Source: New York DEC ↗

Records change as new fish are certified — these were checked in November 2026. Follow each source link for the current official list. Records from other methods (bow, spear, jug line) and catch-and-release length records are kept separately by most agencies and are labelled as such.