Elephant Butte Lake Fishing: Depth, Species & Tips

Elephant Butte Lake is a lake in New Mexico, USA, covering roughly 10,627 acres. Water clarity: Dark, stained (~1.1 m Secchi).

Elephant Butte Lake at a glance

Fish species in Elephant Butte Lake

Also present: Freshwater Drum, American Gizzard Shad, Carps And Minnows.

Species are those recorded within 9 km of the lake in iNaturalist and GBIF records — not an official lake survey. Confirm locally.

Regulations change every year — always confirm the current official rules before you fish.

🏅 Record fish from Elephant Butte Lake

Official records caught in this lake, from state and provincial record lists

Records change as new fish are certified — these were checked in November 2026. Follow each source link for the current official list. Records from other methods (bow, spear, jug line) and catch-and-release length records are kept separately by most agencies and are labelled as such.